

Protecting premium content at internet speed
Read time: 6 minutes

The UK perspective
The UK was one of the first jurisdictions to adapt blocking injunctions to live content. The legal basis is (primarily but not exclusively) section 97A of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, which lets the High Court grant an injunction against a service provider that has actual knowledge of another person using its service to infringe copyright. Rightsholders first used it against static websites. The orders then evolved to cover IP addresses, which are the key focus for rightsholders in the current orders.
The UK perspective
The UK was one of the first jurisdictions to adapt blocking injunctions to live content. The legal basis is (primarily but not exclusively) section 97A of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, which lets the High Court grant an injunction against a service provider that has actual knowledge of another person using its service to infringe copyright. Rightsholders first used it against static websites. The orders then evolved to cover IP addresses, which are the key focus for rightsholders in the current orders.
From websites to servers
In FAPL v BT [2017] EWHC 480 (Ch), the Premier League sought, for the first time, an order aimed at streaming servers rather than a website. Arnold J accepted that viewers were moving to set-top boxes, media players and apps that connect directly to servers by IP address, so website blocking alone could not stop infringement. He called the streaming server “the crucial link in the chain”: blocking a server disrupts every app, website and add-on that uses it.

What makes the order “live”
The Premier League order applies while live match footage is being broadcast. Two technical advances made this possible. First, monitoring can now identify infringing streams accurately in close to real time. Second, ISPs can block and unblock IP addresses during a match, in some cases automatically. The list of target servers is “re-set” each match week. New servers can be added, and old ones drop off; unless they are still seen streaming infringing footage.
Built-in safeguards
The first order was deliberately short, lasting until the end of the 2016/17 season, so that its effectiveness could be assessed. Hosting providers must be notified each week, and effected third parties may apply to vary or set aside the order. Servers are targeted only if they are reasonably believed to exist solely or mainly to enable access to infringing streams. The other selection criteria are confidential to prevent circumvention.
A repeatable model
The order has been renewed season by season. In the 2018 renewal, the evidence showed it had been “very effective” with no overblocking found. The Court widened the set of servers to be blocked and delayed hosting-provider notices to counter circumvention attempts that had actually occurred. The same model has been applied to UEFA competitions, to Matchroom’s boxing events and by various other rightsholders.

The practical requirement is fast detection, fast notification and ISPs that can act within minutes.
Operational lessons for rightsholders
The practical requirement is fast detection, fast notification and ISPs that can act within minutes. Bringing evidence of effectiveness to each renewal also puts the rightsholder in a stronger position. Going forward, the key battleground will be how rightsholders can keep pace with systems employed by pirate operators, whilst ensuring that they do not over block lawful content.
Operational lessons for rightsholders
The practical requirement is fast detection, fast notification and ISPs that can act within minutes. Bringing evidence of effectiveness to each renewal also puts the rightsholder in a stronger position. Going forward, the key battleground will be how rightsholders can keep pace with systems employed by pirate operators, whilst ensuring that they do not over block lawful content.

The practical requirement is fast detection, fast notification and ISPs that can act within minutes.
The EU perspective
The EU now accepts the same commercial reality the UK courts recognized: premium live content loses most of its value in the minutes it is broadcast. The Commission has said that remedies for live transmissions must allow prompt action that reflects their time sensitive element. The difficulty is that the EU has no single court to deliver that speed.
A shared foundation
Article 11 of the Enforcement Directive allows injunctions against intermediaries whose services are used to infringe and refers copyright cases to Article 8(3) of the InfoSoc Directive. In UPC Telekabel Wien (C 314/12), the CJEU confirmed that an ISP can be ordered to block access to an infringing site, provided the court balances the fundamental rights involved. Stichting Brein v Ziggo (C 610/15) extended liability to platforms that organize piracy, which strengthened the case for blocking them.
The EU perspective
The EU now accepts the same commercial reality the UK courts recognized: premium live content loses most of its value in the minutes it is broadcast. The Commission has said that remedies for live transmissions must allow prompt action that reflects their time sensitive element. The difficulty is that the EU has no single court to deliver that speed.
A shared foundation
Article 11 of the Enforcement Directive allows injunctions against intermediaries whose services are used to infringe and refers copyright cases to Article 8(3) of the InfoSoc Directive. In UPC Telekabel Wien (C 314/12), the CJEU confirmed that an ISP can be ordered to block access to an infringing site, provided the court balances the fundamental rights involved. Stichting Brein v Ziggo (C 610/15) extended liability to platforms that organize piracy, which strengthened the case for blocking them.

The outer limit
Scarlet Extended (C 70/10) sets the boundary. A blanket, preventive filtering system applied to all of an ISP’s traffic is not allowed, partly because it could block lawful communications. The Digital Services Act has replaced the E Commerce Directive’s safe harbors with Articles 4 to 8. It keeps the ban on general monitoring and introduces a procedure for orders against specific illegal content. Live orders must therefore be targeted, not open-ended.
Twenty-seven routes to one remedy
Blocking orders are issued and enforced nationally, not by one central court. Dynamic injunctions have been available only in a few Member States, granted either by courts or by administrative authorities that can act on their own initiative or following complaints. Ireland’s Digital Services Act 2024 lets Coimisiún na Meán apply to the High Court for access-blocking orders when the DSA is infringed, subject to a proportionality test.
Going live
The EU is moving toward the FAPL model. The 2023 EU Commission Recommendation on combating online piracy of sports and other live events calls for injunctions against live sports piracy to be dynamic, so that they reach pirate services not identified when proceedings began. Some Member States now grant “live blocking injunctions,” which block an infringing site only while an event, or a series of events such as a football season, is running. However, the Commission’s November 2025 assessment found that response times are often too slow for live events.
Trust flaggers
The DSA’s trusted-flagger regime gives rightsholders a fast lane that is set out in statute. Under Article 22, online platforms must ensure that notices from trusted flaggers, acting within their designated area of expertise, are given priority and processed and decided upon without undue delay. The status is awarded by the Digital Services Coordinator in the Member State where the applicant is established. It is open only to entities, not individuals, that can show expertise in detecting illegal content, independence from platforms and a diligent, accurate and objective approach to notices. Industry associations representing their members’ interests are expressly encouraged to apply. In Ireland, Coimisiún na Meán awards trusted-flagger status for three years. In 2026, it granted the status to the Irish Music Rights Organisation, a copyright collecting society. For sports leagues and broadcasters, the lesson is to channel enforcement through accredited anti-piracy bodies or trade associations, so that notices sent during a match go to the front of the queue. Trusted-flagger status “does not guarantee take-down of content.” It provides a fast track for reporting, but the platform still makes the substantive legal assessment of the content. The DSA does not define “undue delay,” which matters when a stream is only worth stopping during the 90 minutes of the match. Accreditation also comes with obligations. Trusted flaggers must publish detailed reports at least once per year on the notices they submit, and their status can be suspended or revoked. Rightsholders that send inaccurate or poorly evidenced notices therefore risk losing the fast lane altogether.
Article 17: platforms in the front line
Blocking orders target ISPs. Article 17 Copyright in the Digital Single Market tackles a second channel: pirated streams and clips uploaded by users to content-sharing platforms. Under Article 17, the platform itself is treated as making that content available, so it can no longer rely on the traditional “we only host it” defense. Unless it holds a license, the platform is liable; unless it can show three things:
- It must have made best efforts to obtain authorization.
- It must have made best efforts, in accordance with high industry standards of professional diligence to keep out works that rightsholders have identified.
- It must have acted expeditiously on substantiated notices, using best efforts to prevent re-uploads.

Platforms cannot be required to block content where deciding whether it is unlawful would need their own independent assessment.
That screening duty comes with limits. Lawful uploads must not be blocked; this is an obligation of result, not merely of best efforts. Platforms cannot be required to block content where deciding whether it is unlawful would need their own independent assessment. They must also offer complaint mechanisms with human review. The practical lesson for live sports: the duty is triggered by information from rightsholders. Broadcasters who give platforms accurate reference data (such as content fingerprints) before kick-off put the onus on platforms to stop pirated streams during the match. A vague notice sent after the final whistle does far less. Ireland’s transposition reproduces these duties, including the bar on general monitoring and the requirement for a redress mechanism. Rightsholders running pan-European rights face a different forum, evidential standard and timetable in each market. The rightsholders best placed to benefit will be those that use these tools together: certified flaggers, real-time evidence, and a growing body of national case law on live blocking.
That screening duty comes with limits. Lawful uploads must not be blocked; this is an obligation of result, not merely of best efforts. Platforms cannot be required to block content where deciding whether it is unlawful would need their own independent assessment. They must also offer complaint mechanisms with human review. The practical lesson for live sports: the duty is triggered by information from rightsholders. Broadcasters who give platforms accurate reference data (such as content fingerprints) before kick-off put the onus on platforms to stop pirated streams during the match. A vague notice sent after the final whistle does far less. Ireland’s transposition reproduces these duties, including the bar on general monitoring and the requirement for a redress mechanism.
Rightsholders running pan-European rights face a different forum, evidential standard and timetable in each market. The rightsholders best placed to benefit will be those that use these tools together: certified flaggers, real-time evidence, and a growing body of national case law on live blocking.

Platforms cannot be required to block content where deciding whether it is unlawful would need their own independent assessment.
Key takeaways
- Live blocking injunctions are a proven model. UK courts first ordered ISPs to block streaming servers in real time. The orders have been renewed every season with no overblocking found, and the EU is now moving toward the same approach.
- EU enforcement remains fragmented and too slow. Blocking orders are issued separately in each of the 27 Member States, under different procedures and timelines. The Commission’s November 2025 assessment found that response times are often too slow for live events.
- Speed and accurate evidence are the rightsholders’ advantage. The tools that work best together are real-time detection, trusted-flagger status under the DSA, and content fingerprints given to platforms before kick-off. Inaccurate notices can cost a rightsholder its trusted-flagger fast lane.

Key takeaways
- Live blocking injunctions are a proven model. UK courts first ordered ISPs to block streaming servers in real time. The orders have been renewed every season with no overblocking found, and the EU is now moving toward the same approach.
- EU enforcement remains fragmented and too slow. Blocking orders are issued separately in each of the 27 Member States, under different procedures and timelines. The Commission’s November 2025 assessment found that response times are often too slow for live events.
- Speed and accurate evidence are the rightsholders’ advantage. The tools that work best together are real-time detection, trusted-flagger status under the DSA, and content fingerprints given to platforms before kick-off. Inaccurate notices can cost a rightsholder its trusted-flagger fast lane.
Authors
In this edition
In this edition

© Eversheds Sutherland. All rights reserved. Eversheds Sutherland is a global provider of legal and other services operating through various separate and distinct legal entities. Eversheds Sutherland is the name and brand under which the members of Eversheds Sutherland Limited (Eversheds Sutherland (International) LLP and Eversheds Sutherland (US) LLP) and their respective controlled, managed and affiliated firms and the members of Eversheds Sutherland (Europe) Limited (each an "Eversheds Sutherland Entity" and together the "Eversheds Sutherland Entities") provide legal or other services to clients around the world. Eversheds Sutherland Entities are constituted and regulated in accordance with relevant local regulatory and legal requirements and operate in accordance with their locally registered names. The use of the name Eversheds Sutherland, is for description purposes only and does not imply that the Eversheds Sutherland Entities are in a partnership or are part of a global LLP. The responsibility for the provision of services to the client is defined in the terms of engagement between the instructed firm and the client.
Connect with us















