Telescope Logo
Telescope Logo

Disputes and enforcement in the digital content sector

Read time: 4 minutes


For most of the past decade, legal risk in digital content was measured by one number: the regulatory fine. That is changing.

Personal criminal exposure to executives and collective actions against companies are both gaining ground in Europe. They rest on different legal foundations, but they increasingly draw on the same source: the compliance record that platform regulation now requires businesses to build. The result is not a single new liability regime, but a single body of evidence that regulators, prosecutors and claimants can all read.

Person writing

For most of the past decade, legal risk in digital content was measured by one number: the regulatory fine. That is changing.

Personal criminal exposure to executives and collective actions against companies are both gaining ground in Europe. They rest on different legal foundations, but they increasingly draw on the same source: the compliance record that platform regulation now requires businesses to build. The result is not a single new liability regime, but a single body of evidence that regulators, prosecutors and claimants can all read.

Market shift: from public enforcement to multi-front accountability

The EU’s platform rulebook was designed around public enforcement: regulators supervising systemic risks and imposing fines. Two further channels are now developing around it. The first is criminal. High-profile investigations in France involving the leadership of messaging and social media services have shown that prosecutors are prepared to test complicity theories against platform executives; although these proceedings remain at an early stage, and everyone concerned benefits from the presumption of innocence. The second is private. Consumer and privacy organizations, often supported by litigation funders, are bringing collective claims against platforms in a growing number of Member States. What links these channels is less a change in the law of liability than a change in the business model of enforcement. Regulation increasingly generates the facts; private parties and prosecutors increasingly use them. For technology companies, the risk is therefore not only higher; it is more interconnected.

Personal criminal exposure to executives and collective actions against companies are both gaining ground in Europe.

Global legal landscape: Europe sets the frame

Global legal landscape: Europe sets the frame

Criminal liability: still personal by design

European criminal law remains demanding. In France, as elsewhere, no one is criminally liable except for their own conduct, and complicity requires knowing aid or assistance; membership of a management team is not enough. The EU’s Digital Services Act (DSA) does not criminalize anything, and it preserves conditional liability exemptions for intermediaries that act expeditiously on illegal content. That framework remains a significant protection for platforms and their managers. The tension lies elsewhere. The DSA’s due diligence obligations—risk assessments, notice handling, reporting—mean that platforms know more, and can be shown to know more, about what happens on their services. Knowledge is precisely the element that can affect liability exemptions and, in the most serious cases, support allegations of complicity. Compliance is not a source of liability, but it does create the record against which liability will be judged.

Collective actions: harmonized in principle, national in practice

The Representative Actions Directive has applied since 2023, and the DSA has been added to its scope, with users expressly entitled to seek compensation for DSA breaches. Yet, the Directive sets a minimum framework, not a single procedure. France used its transposition in 2025, to unify its group action regime; other Member States are still adjusting theirs. Real activity remains concentrated in a few jurisdictions with effective mechanisms (notably the Netherlands and the UK), and most platform claims are still at an early procedural stage.

Operational impact: compliance documentation becomes evidence

The practical consequence is that compliance work now serves several audiences at once. A systemic risk assessment prepared for a regulator may later be read by an investigating judge or a claimant association. Three features of the current landscape amplify this:

  • Claims increasingly target product design rather than individual content: recommender systems, features used by minors and data processing for advertising.
  • Generative AI raises new questions about whether certain outputs should be treated as third-party content or as the provider’s own.
  • Claimants choose their forum, favoring jurisdictions with opt-out mechanisms and access to large user bases.

None of this means that platform executives face a new wave of prosecutions, or that every Member State is becoming a class action venue. It does mean that fragmented risk management—compliance in one silo, litigation in another, criminal exposure handled only when it arises—is increasingly hard to sustain.

Opportunities: one governance, three audiences

Well-prepared technology companies can turn the same dynamics to their advantage. Because criminal exposure turns on personal knowledge and involvement, clear governance is the most effective protection: documented decision-making, escalation channels that work and genuine delegations of authority. Because the DSA links compliance to compensation, a robust and well-reasoned compliance file does double duty, addressing the regulator while building the defense for any future collective claim. And because collective redress remains national, exposure can be mapped and prioritized country by country, with particular attention to the Netherlands and to jurisdictions moving toward opt-out models. Legal, compliance and litigation teams should therefore work from a single view of risk. That includes drafting compliance documents on the assumption that they may be disclosed and aligning internal communications with formal positions.

Women looking at a laptop

Key takeaways

  1. The convergence is evidential, not doctrinal. Criminal and collective exposure rests on different rules, but they increasingly draw on the same compliance record.
  2. The legal safeguards remain significant. Personal fault requirements, the DSA’s liability exemptions and procedural filters on collective claims continue to protect well-run businesses; the law is still developing, and outcomes remain uncertain.
  3. Manage one risk, not three. Write the compliance file on the assumption that a regulator, an investigating judge and a claimant association may each read it—and build governance that can withstand all three.

Key takeaways

  1. The convergence is evidential, not doctrinal. Criminal and collective exposure rests on different rules, but they increasingly draw on the same compliance record.
  2. The legal safeguards remain significant. Personal fault requirements, the DSA’s liability exemptions and procedural filters on collective claims continue to protect well-run businesses; the law is still developing, and outcomes remain uncertain.
  3. Manage one risk, not three. Write the compliance file on the assumption that a regulator, an investigating judge and a claimant association may each read it—and build governance that can withstand all three.

Author


Nasser Ali Khasawneh

Nasser Ali Khasawneh

Partner, Global Head of Technology & Digital Sector and Global Co-Head of AI, UAE

View profile
Caroline Lyannaz

Caroline Lyannaz

Partner, Digital Content Sub-Sector Co-Lead, France

View profile

In this edition


In this edition


Children on phones

Age assurance as digital infrastructure

Read time: 7 minutes

Read more

Illegal content in the AI supply chain

Read time: 6 minutes

Read more

The content licensing reset

Read time: 5 minutes

Read more

Platform governance across multiple rulebooks

Read time: 5 minutes

Read more

AI agents and consumer liability: new interfaces, new risks

Read time: 8 minutes

Read more

Creators, advertising, and monetization

Read time: 6 minutes

Read more

Protecting premium content at internet speed

Read time: 6 minutes

Read more

Previous page

Next page

Arrow

© Eversheds Sutherland. All rights reserved. Eversheds Sutherland is a global provider of legal and other services operating through various separate and distinct legal entities. Eversheds Sutherland is the name and brand under which the members of Eversheds Sutherland Limited (Eversheds Sutherland (International) LLP and Eversheds Sutherland (US) LLP) and their respective controlled, managed and affiliated firms and the members of Eversheds Sutherland (Europe) Limited (each an "Eversheds Sutherland Entity" and together the "Eversheds Sutherland Entities") provide legal or other services to clients around the world. Eversheds Sutherland Entities are constituted and regulated in accordance with relevant local regulatory and legal requirements and operate in accordance with their locally registered names. The use of the name Eversheds Sutherland, is for description purposes only and does not imply that the Eversheds Sutherland Entities are in a partnership or are part of a global LLP. The responsibility for the provision of services to the client is defined in the terms of engagement between the instructed firm and the client.

Connect with us

linkedin logo
facebook icon
youtube icon